The fast fashion industry is facing a critical turning point, with sustainability becoming an urgent focus amid growing concerns about environmental degradation and unethical labour practices.
As the sector accounts for a significant share of global carbon emissions, water pollution, and textile waste, the demand for more responsible, transparent, and circular practices is intensifying. Consumers and regulators alike are pushing for change, prompting brands to rethink their production models.
Zara
Despite Zara’s stated sustainability goals, current practices, such as increased reliance on air freight and a lack of transparency, indicate that the company faces significant challenges in improving its environmental and social impact.
Fashion for Everyone
Criteria
Carbon Footprint, Low
Zara has declared its goal of achieving net-zero emissions by 2040. However, recent analyses indicate that the company has increased its use of air freight to avoid shipping delays, significantly contributing to carbon emissions.
Ecological Impact, Low
Investigations have linked Zara to deforestation and other environmental damages in Brazil’s Cerrado region. Additionally, the brand’s reliance on synthetic materials like polyester contributes to microplastic pollution.
Energy Consumption, Low
The growing dependence on air freight for distribution has increased Zara’s overall energy consumption, undermining the effectiveness of energy efficiency measures implemented in other areas.
Freight Density, Medium
Zara’s logistics rely heavily on air transport for rapid product delivery, which significantly contributes to the company’s carbon footprint, highlighting inefficiencies in transportation management.
Recycling Rates, Low
Despite announcing sustainability initiatives, Zara lacks transparency in its recycling and waste management programs, making it difficult to assess their effectiveness.
Saving Levels, Medium
There is little publicly available information on economic savings achieved through sustainable practices, suggesting a lack of emphasis on efficiency gains.
Specific Product Monitoring, Low
The absence of transparency and verifiable data makes it difficult to evaluate Zara’s effectiveness in tracking the environmental and social impact of its products throughout their lifecycle.
Supply Chain Waste, Low
Zara has been associated with labour exploitation, including inadequate wages and unsafe working conditions. While the company acknowledges these issues, the effectiveness of corrective measures remains uncertain.
Sustainability Scorecards, Medium
Although Zara publishes sustainability reports, the lack of independent verification and detailed impact assessments raises concerns about the transparency and credibility of its commitments.
Water Management, Low
There is limited publicly available information on Zara’s water management practices, making it difficult to evaluate the company’s impact on this critical resource.
Related to other brands
Number of criteria met by each brand:
- Massimo Dutti 3.5 / 5
- Shein 2.0 / 5
- Zara 3.5 / 5
- Uniqlo 2.5 / 5
ESCP Business School Team
Research developed by five curious international ESCP Business School students who have worked together to successfully complete their consulting project. They analysed four brands in four different categories -24 brands: electric cars EV, dairy products, computers, personal care, luxury apparel, fast fashion-, according to 10 environmental criteria.
- Alix AMMEUX: Dairy Products
- Hanna AMSELLEM: Electrical Vehicles
- Leonardo BERTINI COLLA: Computers
- Zackary BOISNEAULT: Personal Products
- Ariane DESPRES: Luxury Apparels
- Caterina GIUSTINIANI: Fast fashion
Sources
- 233.docx
- SHEIN-2023-Sustainability-and-Social-Impact-Report
- A Study on Sustainable Fashion Supply Chain of Zara
- Value Chain Analysis of Zara – SCM Insight
- Massimo Dutti – Sustainability Facts, Rating, Goals | Panaprium
- Paper | Massimo Dutti Commitment to sustainability
- Sustainable Fast Fashion: How Zara Transforms its Supply Chain – SupplyChain 360
- 2023 Sustainability and Social Impact Report – SHEIN Group
- Sharing our evoluSHEIN Roadmap to Guide the Future of Sustainability & Social Impact at SHEIN – SHEIN Group
- OUR MISSION│Unlocking The Power of Clothing. UNIQLO Sustainability
- The Positive Power of LifeWear | Unlocking The Power of Clothing. UNIQLO Sustainability
0 Comments